About
Writing Out Loud began as a blog of a memoir-in-progress about three generations of daughters and mothers. For several months I posted each chapter as I completed the first draft. My reason for going against time-worn “rules” of creative writing was that, in the post-blog era, I’d become accustomed to instant sharing and sometimes instant feedback, and I just couldn’t bear the isolation of the long-distance writer anymore. (By long-distance I mean the writing of novels or other book-length projects.)
I viewed this as an experiment, and while I wouldn’t exactly call it a failure, I can’t say it was a raging success. That doesn’t matter really. What does matter is that I’ve come to believe this experiment isn’t productive–it isn’t good for my writing process, or my ego, to be sharing first drafts. Annie Lamott calls it The Shitty First Draft and advises writers to allow themselves complete freedom at this stage. Improving the writing quality can wait until revision. Even before I read Lamott, I had long subscribed to the theory of right-brain/left-brain writing: one is creative and free-flowing, while the other must become the judgmental editor who shapes and revises the work (sorta like good cop/bad cop).
And so I have deleted all the chapters that were on this blog. I’ve left the process journals, the poems, and any other writing relevant to my memoir about mother/daughterhood (which is turning out to be primarily about my relationship with my mother, period). I don’t know if what’s left is enough to sustain a blog and/or interest readers–although a lot of users tend to search for poems about motherhood, and end up here.
If it’s not enough, dissatisfied readers can click their way over to my primary blog,
Dirty Laundry, where you’ll find many posts on the subject of motherhood. (Most Dirty Laundry readers seem to go there for the racier stuff–the erotica, sexy poetry, and opinion pieces on topics related to sexuality.)
A word about the journal postings: I learned the benefits of keeping a process journal from Louise DeSalvo’s book, Writing as a Way of Healing. My creative writing students kept them in tandem with class projects as per my instructions. It’s a place to put all the spillover emotions generated by the writing of a particular book. It includes material that may not end up in the book itself, but that demands some kind of expression.
I hope readers aren’t disappointed and will understand, maybe even learn something from my experiment. Who knows? I may change my mind again someday. Never say never.
![]()
The URI to TrackBack this entry is: http://marcysmemoir.wordpress.com/trackback/
Good morning:
I came across you after my first week writing a blog.
I am still asking myself-why am I doing this?
Someone sent me the suggestion that if I was less serious, more light-hearted I would have more readers and responders. I am surprised at how strongly this suggestion pulls at me, that I did not dismiss it, delete it immediately. Slowly and surely the true notion won out; it is not for readers that I write, it is to sort out who I am as I become what I am.
Finding your words is just right, I’ll get back to putting one word after another.
Thanks.
Thank you for your comment. I’m glad I’ve helped you stick to what you want to do, what you believe in. When I first started blogging, I was maniacal about trying to get readers. At this point I’ve plateau’d out at an average of 100 a day (according to WordPress’s system–it could be more) on my primary blog, Dirty Laundry. It never gets any higher, and I’ve decided I don’t care; maybe it is because I’m too serious, but I don’t know how to write any other way. This blog only draws in 3-15 people a day, and that’s fine with me. I do long for more feedback, however. Anyhow, thanks for stopping by. I’ll come visit your blog soon.–MS
Outside criticism never comes in the right size or quality because we ourselves don’t know what we want to hear. Is it good? Bad? Fixable? Or not? None of these questions without real answers seem to be really relevant when it comes right down to it. I think what we are asking is, “Did my writing touch you?” That’s an interesting question that is not quantifiable, nor is it ever the same answer from second to second. Perhpaps all we can hope for is the possibility of being read, being seen when we decide to move out of invisibility, like the possibility that electrons will show up where they are expected and in the form we can recognize. Otherwise we are all invisible to one another.
I may be following in your footsteps to a degree. Started a Crime Story in progress on my blog Label It Crime yesterday . . . And I wondered how I’d find the experience, good? bad? helpful? debilitating? So finding your memoir in progress and consequently abandoned is good info for me to have. I’m going to go ahead and give the Label It Crime blog a go for a month. That’s the plan.
I generally read your daily post and enjoy your prose style as well as your poetry. And I have actually gone to the paypal link but when it asks for an address [?] I pull a blank and abandon the donation process. Do you have a “donate” button somewhere? Your work is worth more than my donation will be, but a little is better than none . . . right?
Thanks so much for your comments. I’ve been to your site, as you know, and I’m looking forward to reading your new crime story…that’s exciting!
When Paypal asks for an address, I’m sure they must mean the URL. Mine is http://www.marcys.wordpress.com. I cannot post their buttons because WordPress has some doodad that knocks out that kind of code. I will be eternally grateful for your donation, or anyone else’s. Hell, I’m grateful you even considered it!–MS